Best Hunting Boots of 2019 – Complete Reviews With Comparison

Best Hunting Boots of 2018 Complete Reviews With Comparison
Spread the love

What you need in a hunting boot is pretty clear: something warm and comfortable that will keep your feet dry even in the worst of weather conditions.

Finding the best hunting boots, however, isn’t always quite so clear. With hundreds of options on the market, it’s not easy to sort through them all to figure out which pair is best for you.

This guide narrows down these choices to the top five best, including information on which features matter most.

Contents

Top 5 Best Hunting Boots Comparison Chart

Irish Setter Men’s 2870 Vaprtrek Waterproof 8″ Hunting Boot, Realtree Xtra Camouflage,9.5 D US

Muck Arctic Pro Tall Rubber Insulated Extreme Conditions Men’s Hunting Boots, Bark, 12 M US

Danner Men’s Pronghorn Realtree Xtra 1200G Hunting Boot,Brown/Realtree,13 EE US

LaCrosse Men’s Alphaburly Pro 18” 1600G Hunting Boot,Realtree Xtra,12 M US

Wolverine Men’s Claw Insulated Waterproof-M Hunting Boot Brown/Realtree 8.5 M US

Best Hunting Boots Reviews

1. Irish Setter Men's 2870 Hunting Boot

This is a mid-range hunting boot from well-known brand Irish Setter, which has been a great name in hunting boots for over 100 years. Red Wing Shoes, the parent brand behind Irish Setter, has done a great job of updating Irish Setter through the years.

Product Highlights

These 7” shoes are a great early season pair of boots that feature ScentBan technology, a lightweight rubber sole, and extreme durability to ensure these shoes will last for many seasons to come.

What's to like about the Irish Setter Men's 2870 Hunting Boot

This boot stands out among the back because of the incredible durability that they afford the wearer. The synthetic outer material and rubber sole stand up to snow, heat, and other conditions without breaking down.

Additionally, these shoes are the most comfortable to wear. They keep your feet support, dry, sturdy, and warm throughout a number of conditions. Since the shoes are so lightweight, you can move around quickly, and your feet are well-supported throughout all activities.

What's not to like about the Irish Setter Men's 2870 Hunting Boot

While the overall shoe is very durable, the tread doesn’t hold up as well as the rest of the shoe, so you may find yourself needing to replace the shoe for tread reasons instead of for holes or other durability issues.

These boots are not insulated. They can be worn with socks for good, basic insulation; the boots themselves only feature waterproof technology, not any sort of insulation grading.

PROS

  • check
    High durability ranking
  • check
    Very comfortable to wear & easy to break-in
  • check
    Ultra-dry technology keeps water out

CONS

  • Not insulated
  • Tread wears out more quickly than the rest of the boot

2. MuckBoots Men's Arctic Pro Hunting Boot

Muck Boots are known to be the boots that keep your feet dry, and for a mid-range price, they will! These are some of the best cold weather hunting boots known to man, so they are worth checking out to find if they’re the right hunting boots for you.

Product Highlights

These boots are most known for two things – the fact that they can keep feet warm in temperatures from -60° to 40° F and that they are comfortable at the same time thanks to the great EVA midsole that helps to absorb shock from any terrain you are dealing with.

What's to like about the MuckBoots Men's Arctic Pro Hunting Boot

Our favorite part of these boots is the 4-way stretch shaft part of the boot. This nylon has some give, so you can easily pull these boots on and off. Additionally, the same material ensures you have warm feet while keeping the cold out.

Like all Muck Boots, these are 100% waterproof. The neoprene lining inside the shoe prevents any water from penetrating the shoe while also allowing air to circulate. This is key so that your feet don’t get damp inside the shoe.

What's not to like about the MuckBoots Men's Arctic Pro Hunting Boot

One major drawback of these shoes is that they can in no way be considered an all-season boot. While you could make them warmer by layering up, it is impossible to use these in warmer weather because they will get entirely too warm.

Another drawback is that these boots are not durable enough for everyday use in very tough conditions. With regular use, the neoprene and areas around the heel are susceptible to cracking, which would render them useless.

PROS

  • check
    Insulated with two types of insulation
  • check
    100% waterproof with neoprene lining
  • check
    Comfortable, supportive EVA foam inner sole

CONS

  • Not durable enough to deal with rugged terrain
  • Top may be too small for those with larger calves
  • Not an all-season boot

3. Danner Men's Pronghorn 1200G Hunting Boot

This is high-end men’s hunting boot made by the growing brand Danner, who are known for their unique, comfortable designs made for a variety of outdoor applications.

Product Highlights

This Danner boot is a fantastic waterproof boot with 1,200g insulation rating. It is made of a combination of high-quality leather and Gore-Tex treated fabric for a great fit that will keep your feet dry and warm into the winter season.

What's to like about the Danner Men's Pronghorn 1200G Hunting Boot

The GORE-TEX waterproof construction on this boot is unlike any others that we’ve covered so far. This type of lining is between the outer leather and the inner fabric, and it prevents any type of water, wind, or chill from reaching your feet while wearing your Danner’s.

Additionally, the boots are well insulated at 1,200g. This is a great amount for late fall and winter season hunting when you won’t be doing much activity, such as time spent in a tree stand. The insulation used is Thinsulate, one of the most popular types of insulation.

What's not to like about the Danner Men's Pronghorn 1200G Hunting Boot

These boots are very well insulated, but that makes them very bulky. You may find that your step becomes much clunkier in these boots. Don’t expect to be able to run or make other quick movements while wearing these. If you want that, look for Danner’s 400g insulated boots.

Another drawback is that the toe area of the boot wears down much more rapidly than the rest of the boot. This is likely because the material is stretched thinner there, but scuffing will be apparent in that area very quickly.

PROS

  • check
    Very well insulated, rated at 1,200g
  • check
    GORE-TEX waterproof construction keeps water out without any issues
  • check
    Lightweight and easy to find the right fit

CONS

  • While the shoe is lightweight, it’s still too bulky
  • Front toe area isn’t as durable as the rest of the shoe

4. LaCrosse Men’s Alphaburly Pro 1600G Hunting Boot

These hunting boots made by LaCrosse are a high-end solution to the problem that all hunters face as the snow falls and the temperature drops: cold feet. With this boot’s intense insulation, your feet won’t be cold any longer.

Product Highlights

This boot, largely made of rubber and neoprene, is an expert shoe for the expert hunter that needs warm, dry, and comfortable feet even as temperatures take a nosedive in the coldest of winter months. Both flexible and waterproof, you can’t go wrong with LaCrosse.

What's to like about the LaCrosse Men’s Alphaburly Pro 1600G Hunting Boot

The insulation and waterproof treatments on this boot are insane. There is a 3.55mm neoprene core that prevents water from getting in, and just in case, there is a premium coat of rubber around this core. This combination ensures feet stay dry.

Because these boots are so warm, it’s possible that your feet might get sweaty, and it’s not good to have damp feet. These boots have a wicking lining inside which helps keep any moisture that develops away from your feet.

What's not to like about the LaCrosse Men’s Alphaburly Pro 1600G Hunting Boot

Because of the style of the boot, they can be difficult to remove. They are a bit tight around the ankle area, and there is no type of grasp point on the back to help pull the boot off. This can be incredibly frustrating.

While they are warm, they are not as durable as other boots. Stepping on a branch or rock the wrong way could tear the neoprene, leading to leaks that will soak your feet in no time.

PROS

  • check
    Insulated at 1,600g, perfect for cold temps
  • check
    Neoprene and rubber core keep water out of the shoe
  • check
    Ultra-wicking inner lining prevents moisture build up on feet

CONS

  • Very hard to get on and off of your feet compared to other styles
  • Not very durable
  • Sizing is complicated

5. Wolverine Men's Claw Hunting Boot

The Wolverine Men’s Claw boots are a great mid-range pair that stands out for their flexibility of usage when it comes to terrain, season, and style. No matter what you need, the Claw might be able to provide it for you.

Product Highlights

These leather boots are a durable pair of boots that are made for applications where you need to be on your feet and keep moving. The shoes feature a dura shock sturdy suspension to keep your feet stable as you move quickly across medium-difficult terrain without missing a step.

What's to like about the Wolverine Men's Claw Hunting Boot

The best thing about these boots is how easy it is to move while wearing them. The 6.5” shaft is low for some hunting applications, but great when you expect to be moving quickly. The shoes are relatively lightweight, so you can keep moving without any risk of injury.

Additionally, these boots can be expected to last for a long time thanks to the rubberized toe compartment and aggressive tread. Soles and toe areas are known to go first on boots, but these are reinforced to prevent any durability issues.

What's not to like about the Wolverine Men's Claw Hunting Boot

These have an insulation rating of 200g, which is good for early and fall season hunting but won’t be enough to keep your feet warm if you plan on camping out in a tree stand for a couple of hours.

Another potential problem with these boots is that they do not come up very high on your ankle. This means that you are at a higher risk of getting wet or cold if dealing with inclement weather.

PROS

  • check
    Waterproof and 200g insulation rating
  • check
    Very durable, especially in the tread and toe box
  • check
    Great for high-action hunting situations

CONS

  • Not ideal for cold weather
  • Shaft only comes up 6.5”

BUYER'S GUIDE

When looking for great hunting boots, there are a few features that you should always consider before making a final selection.

 If you don’t think about these key aspects of your boots, you’ll wind up with wet feet or breaking them in just a few wears. Be smart and consider the following before making any purchases.

Types of Hunting Boots

Rather than just being one distinct type of boot, there are various types of hunting boots. Each boot has a different primary function, so knowing the difference in categories will help you make your final selection.

The most popular types of hunting boots include:

Upland Boots

A very lightweight boot intended for wear when walking long distances on moderate terrain. Design features a tread that will not pick up much dirt or mud.

High Country Boots

A heavyweight boot designed for high altitudes where steeper terrain, rougher landscapes, and colder temps could be an issue. Extreme durability and support.

Multi-purpose Boots

A mix-and-match type of boot, depending on your needs. Can be worn on a variety of terrains and come in a variety of insulation grades. Available at many price points.

Rubber Boots

Waterproof boots ideal for hunting in murky, wet environments such as marshes or swamps. Should be 100% watertight.

Over boots

Not a boot in-and-of itself. A kind of boot cover that adds insulation and waterproof protection to another pair of boots or shoes.

Insulation/Waterproofing

If your feet get wet or cold while out on a hunt, you’ll come back shivering and won’t be very happy with how the overall trip went.

The amount of insulation you need is directly dependent on the type of hunting you are doing. If you plan to hole up in a tree stand in freezing temps, you want a highly insulated boot. If you plan to be chasing an animal down in milder temps, you want thin insulation, so you don’t get too warm.

This basic breakdown of insulation ranges should help you decide how much insulation you should look for in your ideal pair of hunting boots:

1,000 grams or greater insulation

The highest amount of insulation available. Great for the harshest of winter days when you will be doing the least amount of activity.

400 grams to 900 grams

Mid-range of insulation. Good for days when you’ll be moving moderately or days when the weather is starting to get cold. Great for most fall days.

Less than 200 grams

A boot with little to no insulation is good for conditions where you will be moving a lot and risk becoming too warm, such as trailing elk or running.

Also, consider how waterproof any boot you are interested in is. If you go out hunting in an unprotected shoe, your feet will be wet in no time either because of the dew on the grass or from crossing small creeks and streams.

Boot Material

There are a number of materials that hunting boots are made out of. Each has their pros and cons and are best for different applications.

Rubber

Rubber is one of the most commonly used materials when creating hunting boots. In fact, nearly every hiking boot has some rubber on the sole or another part of the boot.

It’s important to remember that there are many different types of rubber and each one will act differently.  Generally speaking, rubber is great for the following reasons:

  • Durable
  • Waterproof
  • Lightweight
  • Easy-to-clean
  • Inexpensive
  • Balanced
  • Leather

Leather has been used to make hunting boots for hundreds of years, and that practice will not be ending anytime soon. Like rubber, there are many different qualities and types of leather, so the effectiveness of a leather hiking boot will depend on the specific material used.

Cheap leather will leave your feet wet, be fairly uncomfortable, and be impossible to move without making a lot of noise. Doesn’t sound ideal for a hunt, does it?

Mid-grade and high-quality leather, however, is a completely different story.

These materials are very comfortable because they naturally stretch to fit over time. Additionally, they are durable and stand up to scuffs well. If treated properly, they have a great degree of waterproofness as well.

Gore-Tex

Gore-Tex is a thin lining that goes between the inner and outer layers of a hunting boot. This material is synthetic, and its unique construction makes the boot nearly watertight. Additionally, Gore-Tex keeps wind, rain, and other chills from affecting you through your boots.

Neoprene

Similar to Gore-Tex, neoprene is a lining used in some hunting boots, particularly in those used for very cold and snowy conditions. Neoprene, originally developed for use in wetsuits, does a great job of keeping water out and heat in.

Sole Material

Make sure to check what sole material is used in the top choices on your hunting boots list.

You need to ensure that the boots will have a durable, puncture-proof, and lightweight sole. Many different materials can accomplish this goal (including composite materials, rubber, and leather), and the perfect material will depend on your needs.

Weight

While small differences in weight might not seem like much, they will make a big difference after a long hunting trek that involves covering a lot of distance.

Boots can weight anywhere from mere ounces to over 5 pounds. Consider that you will be picking up more weight as you go due to moisture, mud, and other debris.

Generally speaking, the lightest, durable boot you can find is best. We recommend not getting anything that weighs more than 2 pounds.

Hunting Boots F.A.Q.

Are Muck Boots Waterproof?

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.

Are Irish Setter Boots Made In USA?

Unfortunately, there is not a clear-cut answer to this question. All boots made by Irish Setter are made from imported materials. Some of their boots are made in the USA; some are not. You can filter their products on the Irish Setter Boots website to find styles made in the USA.

How Many Grams of Thinsulate Do I Need?

As mentioned in the insulation section above, the amount of insulation you will need depends on what kind of hunting situation you will be in.

If you are going to be walking all day in late fall and early winter temperatures, between 400 and 600 grams of insulation should be enough. If you will be staying in one spot all day, you will need more. If you will be staying still all day in 0° or colder temperatures, you will need 2,000 grams of insulation (plus warm socks!)

What Size Muck Boot Should I Get?

The easiest way to find the correct fit in a Muck Boot is to look at your tennis shoes or sneakers. Choose the same size in Muck Boot that you wear in an athletic shoe.

If you are a half size, go up to the next whole size for the best fit.

How to Insulate Your Boots?

The best way to insulate boots that don’t have enough built-in insulation is to buy over-boot covers. These covers are made to keep the cold from getting into your boots while you are hunting. They prevent the cold from seeping in.

FINAL VERDICT

It’s clear to see from our in-depth reviews that the Irish Setter Men's 2870 Hunting Boot is one of the best hunting boots because of their lightweight, high-durability rating that is sure to get you through any season of hunting. Additionally, they’re comfortable to wear in most hunting applications.

If you would prefer a more inexpensive option, then Wolverine Men's Claw Hunting Boot can be considered one of the top hunting boots for those who have a slightly tighter budget.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Comment: